Old High Riser Blog

Tuesday, February 4, 2025

My railway station, for now

With the opening of Anzac Station and the Metro Tunnel this year, South Yarra Station will be less used by me. 

To travel on the Pakenham or Cranbourne lines, I will use Anzac Station as those trains will cease to travel via South Yarra Station, diving underground just before they reach the station.

Anzac Station is a five minute walk for me, or one stop on a tram. I am not sure whether I will continue to use what will become less crowded trams to travel to the city, or use the train. Assuming the train has a very frequent clock face service, I will almost certainly use it to travel to the northern area of the city, using Museum Station, but only real life travel can tell me whether it will be better to reach the closer Town Hall Station. The slow part of the tram trip is once it reaches the city, with traffic lights very hostile to trams. 

Time will  tell. If travelling by train to areas west of the city, while it may take a little longer, I often catch  a tram to South Yarra, and then a train that runs through the city and out to the west. It seems when the Metro Tunnel opens, these through trains will revert to using the underground City Loop, although possible another line might offer a through service from South Yarra Station.

I quite like South Yarra Station, though it has changed a lot over a couple of decades, with the front rebuilt and opened up wider. Pre Covid, it was neck to neck with Caulfield Station as the busiest outside of the city stations. This will certainly change when the Metro Tunnel opens, with quite a substantial drop in patronage at South Yarra and an increase at Caulfield. 

Here are a few photos of South Yarra Station. There is lots of seating to the left of this photo, and the level boarding tram stops could not be any closer. If you look at my header photo, the station is just before the tall buildings. 

I think the modern timberwork works quite well. Until I looked at these photos, I had not noticed how nice the windows are. Gates are now plentiful and to the right of this photo is the ticket office. 


This screen alternates between displaying passing tram times and nearby Chapel Street trams.


These screens inform passengers with train information. 


This one generally displays 'good service' for all train lines, until it doesn't. 


Improvements to the station could be lifts for each pair and individual platforms as the rams are quite steep. Ray used to always moan about the steepness of the ramp. So much for the power of Baby Boomers. There has a been a lot of intensive apartment development to the north of the station, so it also now needs northern platform entrances. 

31 comments:

  1. It's a burgeoning, growing community, and it's good that transportation links are growing alongside.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is JB. It's a pity public transport is so poor in our outer areas though. The Metro Tunnel should help many.

      Delete
  2. I am impressed by your city's public transport system. It seemed pretty good when I last visited many, many years ago.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. JayCee, it was pretty tired back when you visited. Quicker now? No. More comfortable, yes.

      Delete
  3. I haven't explored Metro tunnel yet but it seems exciting to take on new stations and train service. After all, they cost so much

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Roentare, it will be money well spent. You will be amazed when you see it.

      Delete
  4. For a guy who is a self-confessed transport nerd, these tram and train questions must be like manna from heaven! Just don't get over-excited Andrew or you might need to change your underpants!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am not such a person as you describe YP, and nor am I a foamer who gets very excited by public transport. What is your term? Something about anoraks.

      Delete
  5. When we come to Melbourne we use both train and tram but when the train development began they cut out the through tram to Carlton from South Yarra which was disappointing. Can you get them to fix it Andrew and while you are at it tell them to put user friendly trams with knee saving steps rather than the old ones they use on Chapel Street . I love Melbourne trams.
    During Covid the trains were spotless , these days not so much.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. At least I know which Anon you are now. That would be route 8 to Melbourne Uni, I suppose. I can't see that changing. The long E Class trams can't run in Swanston Street. I would guess it will be about three years before low floor trams operate in Chapel Street. I don't think the trains are too dirty. I see cleaners going through them at times as the trains are operating. But it only takes one nasty mess to put you off.

      Delete
  6. I used to love South Yarra Station but I doubt I would recognise it now.
    Just like all the old stations on the Frankston line. There was a time when touching anything with a whiff of heritage was sacrilege but times are a'changing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Merlot, they haven't done a bad job of retaining the heritage aspects of South Yarra. Aside from the modern information systems and wider mouth, it is not so different.

      Delete
  7. You are all over the place, aren't you?

    ReplyDelete
  8. On the Pakenham line, I am so looking forward to the opening of the Metro tunnel and new stations. Hoping it will be quicker for us to get to the city, and we won't have to go around the loop

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. J, I will guess it will be express Caulfield or Malvern to Anzac Station. The train in theory can travel at a very high speed. As it dives underground before South Yarra Station, it should be about two minutes to Anzac Station and then two minutes to Town Hall Station.

      Delete
  9. That train station looks as up-to-date as any modern airport.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kirk, yes the screens are good and there are staff there too. Yet, it is a very old station and its history has been retained.

      Delete
  10. Interesting. I guess you are looking forward to the openings when they arrive.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed Margaret, I am excited about it opening but sad that Ray won't get to ride it.

      Delete
  11. Is that last photo the "steep" ramp? It doesn't look too bad, just a long incline, probably similar to the Adelaide Railway Station ramp which I still use.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. River, it is a good bit steeper than Adelaide Station's ramp, as I remember it. Ray didn't complained about the steepness or your ramp. The camera can lie.

      Delete
  12. It all looks very modern your transport system, here Manchester is also undertaking, very slowly, a transformation in the city centre, less cars more trams.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thelma, we spent a couple of days there five years ago and used the ok tram. It wasn't a fast service but quite ok. The grimy industrial cities in the north of England have and are changing quickly.

      Delete
  13. I used the light rail system in Phoenix to go to the airport yesterday morning. A nice ride and for someone my age, only $1. It is a nice, but not extensive system.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. TP. I hope it expands, as they often do when they are successful.

      Delete
  14. Lifts would be a great idea.
    Sandra sandracox.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  15. Several decades ago our US state of Ohio supposedly planned a high speed rail line between the northeast and southwestern regions. My husband and I would have continued visiting family more if it had been completed and well maintained. Ah, well. We did meet family members halfway a few days ago. Best wishes, my dear.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Darla, it sounds like a no brainer railway line, that would immediately be successful.

      Delete